skip to content

Tuna Melt

APRIL 29, 2024 BY KIMBERLY

Tuna salad with pickles, mustard and herbs, under melted cheese on crispy bread. Twenty minutes, the classic diner lunch at home.

READY IN20 minMAKES2 sandwichesDIFFICULTYeasy peasyDIETmeat & fish

your own shopping list, swaps and what to serve with it, all in the recipe below.

EVERY RECIPE DESERVES

A little love letter

Dear tuna melt,

Crispy outside, molten inside, a little bit messy. You don't pretend to be anything else, and I love you for it.

You start with a tuna cream that's sharper than it has any right to be: pickle, lemon, garlic, a bit of Dijon, dill and chives. Then red onion, slices of jalapeño, cheddar and mozzarella between two slices of bread, all pressed into a buttery pan until the cheese gives up and runs out the sides.

That first bite, with the crunch and the cheese pull and the jalapeño kicking in late, makes any lunch feel like a small win. You're my answer to a grey day when I want comfort with a bit of attitude. A dash of Tabasco, and you're perfect.

Let’s make this piece of happinessxo, Kimberly

Kimberlysaved you a seat
p.s. make the tuna cream the night before and lunch is basically a 10-minute job.
FRESH OUT OF THE KITCHEN

Up close

Tuna Melt

Tuna salad with pickles, mustard and herbs, under melted cheese on crispy bread. Twenty minutes, the classic diner lunch at home.

GOOD TO KNOW
READY IN20 minMAKES2 sandwichesDIFFICULTYeasy peasyDIETmeat & fishSTART ATON THE TABLE AT
Tuna Melt – Crispy, Cheesy, with Jalapeno
From my kitchen to yours

Hi, I’m Kimberly. The kitchen is my happy place, and everything that turns out really good there ends up here. Including the little tricks I’d usually only tell my friends. more about me

come say hi
Kimberlythat’s me
INGREDIENTS
UNITS
SCALE
for the tuna creme
for the other ingredients
something to drink?
INSTRUCTIONStap the number when a step is done
1

slice the onion

Peel the onion, halve it, and slice it into fine half circles. Set aside.
2

slice the jalapeño

Wash the jalapeño and slice it into thin rings. Set aside.
3

prep the mozzarella

Squeeze the mozzarella in paper towels to remove as much moisture as possible, then slice it thinly. Set aside.
4

make the tuna cream

For the tuna cream: Drain the can of tuna so there's no water left. Place the tuna in a medium-sized bowl. Mix it with mayonnaise, lemon juice, Dijon mustard, salt, and pepper. Now chop the pickle into small pieces and add it to the bowl. Finely chop the dill and chives and add them to the bowl as well. Peel and finely chop the garlic clove, or press it into the bowl. Mix everything together. Season to taste and set aside.
5

build the sandwiches

Heat a pan over medium heat without adding any additional fat. Meanwhile, spread a little butter on two slices of bread. Place the bread slices in the pan, buttered side down. Spread each with half of the tuna cream, then top with the red onions. Add half of the mozzarella and a slice of cheddar cheese to each. Top with the jalapeño slices. Let it all cook for a few minutes on low to medium heat.
6

close & flip

Meanwhile butter the other two bread slices. Once the bottom of the bread in the pan is golden brown and crispy, place the other bread slices, buttered side up, on top of the sandwiches in the pan. Use a spatula to lift the sandwich and quickly flip it, so it can brown on the other side.
7

melt the cheese

Let everything cook for another 5-8 minutes on low heat, allowing the cheese to melt and the bread slice to become crispy.
8

serve

Remove from the pan and cut in half. Serve immediately, drizzle with Tabasco to taste and enjoy your pieces of happiness.
ASKED & ANSWEREDtap a question
Why squeeze the mozzarella?
It holds a lot of water. Squeezed dry, it melts without making the bread soggy.
The bread is done but the cheese isn’t melted.
Turn the heat down and put a lid on the pan for a minute or two. The steam melts the cheese while the bread stays golden.
Can I make the tuna cream ahead?
Yes, it keeps for up to 2 days in a closed container in the fridge.
Which bread works best for a tuna melt?
A sturdy one with a tight crumb, like sourdough or a good sandwich loaf. Very airy bread lets the tuna cream soak through.
MORE THAN RECIPES

Cook by moment

menus, stories and the recipes that go with them.
SEE ALL MOMENTS
MADE IT?

Then show me

Post a photo and tag me @kimberlyzett. I love seeing every single one.

TAG ME ON INSTAGRAM
Homemade Kimchiyour version?
Katsu Sandotag me in this one
Bacon Onion Cheese Rollsshow me yours
Pumpkin Souplilly approves
MADE IT?

Tell me how it went

THE GUEST BOOK0 entries
sign the guest book
see you in
your inbox?
LOVE LETTERS

Let’s stay in touch

New recipes, little kitchen moments and the occasional strong opinion about butter. If you don’t want to miss a thing, it’s all in your inbox or on my socials.